Some notes after viewing "Aguirre, the Wrath of God"

[clear]

Not like it’s an uncommon subject around here, but the other night Marty and I briefly discussed those big life changes where either through a sudden disruption or a slow, almost unnoticed disintegration, one opens one’s eyes to find that one is either on the edge or dead center of not just a spiritual but an organizational chaos where the old order of viewing, classifying and filing experience not only does not work but is absolutely hosed.

No, not an uncommon subject. We’ve discussed this for decades.

Marty believes everyone goes through this process and that it is a part of an essential reassessment that begins in the twenties. a growing up and beyond the world into which one has been indoctrinated, since birth, by parents and various institutions.

I agree in part, on a basic level, and have often enough watched people hit their mid to late twenties whose confidence suddenly wavers as they’re walking down the stairs of their apartment building, they’ve seen a glitch in the shadows off to the side, something’s not measuring up, not even if they believed they were well-formed independent thinkers, and they’re shaken by just how many little questions arise and inflate into giant dirigibles haunting the once familiar countryside.

But then again I don’t believe it is something everyone goes through…or should I say it isn’t an experience to which everyone submits (and Marty agrees with me on this more times than not so there is no “then again” or “on the other hand” about it, it’s just that sometimes he gives people more credit than I believe they deserve, just as he also insists that I often give people more credit than they deserve, one or the other depending on the weather). A good deal of fortitude is required, if one is deeply entrenched socially and career-wise in prefabricated boxes, to admit to re-evaluations that may risk laying waste those maps one accepted from youth as writ on stone, whatever the alphabet used.

I’m not just talking questioning authority. Questioning authority is a must and a good thing for all, yet a first step from which many recoil in mid stride, the dogs barking out all kinds of warnings of disasters to come considering the laws of falling dominoes. There’s a difference between a teenage rebelliousness that can easily morph into taking up the flag of the responsible status quo, and, in your twenties, thinking hard over a former seeming natural dispensation for Miracle Whip or mayo and finding there lies the slippery road to ruin. Nor am I talking Losing One’s Day Planner and waking up wondering, “Where am I?!” once or twice. But Losing One’s Day Planner once, then twice, then on the third time finding in its place a staff and cockleshell offers opportunity to resolutely flee the shadow of something greater before it decides you’re on friendly terms, the chances perhaps less than zero that without some personal initiative you’ll find yourself on a mountain, that staff now a lightning rod, the bolt that comes out of the blue leaving a whiff of both a scintillating and terrifying ozone in the scorched wake of which you now have all the time in the world to reflect on an infinite number of briefly illuminated seemingly relevant details, except you are badly burned and damned if you can remember why you were standing there in the first place.

I began trying to approach this some in the Penguin book–well, didn’t exactly begin there, as a couple plays of mine had this as their base as well as another previous book, but the Penguin novel took it a bit further and I have been hoping to work with this more in the book I’ve laboring on the past couple years.

In the Penguin book, the more boiled down relation of the process is via the giggly subatomic particles whose idea of the punch line of a good joke is miles beyond when you’re ready to lie down and have a good, refreshing nap.

There’s a reason why Dionysus, bearing the gift of the jolly wine (let’s not insist on literalism, which has caused lots of problems historically) is the god who causes people to slip prisons..is also a god who is torn asunder.

Thursday night, I watched Werner Herzog’s “Aguirre, the Wrath of God” again. The movie had been in the Netflix cue for a long while, and this past weekend I had viewed a good portion of Herzog’s “My Best Fiend” which had clips from “Aguirre” and reminded me that I’ve been planning for a year to watch it. What moved me, finally, to watch it on Netflix Thursday night was reading Jim McCulloch’s The Resonance of History, in which he relates some of his experiences while living in South America. He speaks of a period of his faith in science being unsettled following a brush with what might be described as an extra-personal yet all motivating breath (I can’t even palely paraphrase his beautiful, eloquent account)…and I don’t know how that resolved but he also mentions in contrast Cabeza de Vaca, who throughout his amazing (sometimes too incredible, for my money) wanderings in “The New World”, never lost faith in the institutions of his youth.

Had Cabeza lost faith then we’d not have visions of him crossing the desert, healing in the names of his Spanish gods, eventually followed by a crowd of hundreds of curious Indians. Jim recognizes a great story when he sees one, which he does in the barest details of Cabeza’s slim memoir, and beckons us to Picture in your mind this vast throng of diverse Indians walking through the desert toward the sunset, led by lean bearded men who healed in the name of the Jesus and the Virgin. Nothing like this had ever happened before, or has ever happened since.

What better promo for loyalty to one’s faith is that (would make a great movie, no?) and far more inviting than all those saints (old old world gods with little toes shorn off the better to fit them into new shoes) and their spurious martyrdoms urging devotion to a party which in its bullying literalism had more to do with divine right political leverage than revelation. “Admirable!” some would say. “Miraculous!” would say others. And I’m a little surprised Cabeza de Vaca wasn’t nominated for sainthood, except he was later critical about Old World treatment of the New World indigenous.

Still, though I am amazed by Cabeza de Vaca’s resilience and determination, eight years ago my gut reaction to reading his memoir was that his ability to cart the Old World along with him and persist in viewing all through its filter was not so marvelous as an astonishing blindness–unless he didn’t reveal in his memoir what he actually thought.

As Jim points out in his The Resonance of History, there were conquistadors who plunged into “The New World” claiming everything in sight for those old institutions, and people too who were instead conquered by “The New World”, some of whom may have eventually attempted to straddle both with a foot on each shore but it’s difficult to be in two places at once.

“Aguirre, the Wrath of God” concerns an expedition which stalls and, the expressed belief being that both hostile Indians and the fabled city of El Dorado are within a few days’ journey, an exploratory group is sent down river on several rafts, who are supposed to return with their report in the space of a week or be considered lost.

One of the great moments in “Aguirre, the Wrath of God” is toward the end when all on the last remaining raft, floating down the Amazon, weakened by hunger and illness, begin to suffer hallucinations.

The imposition of the Old World upon the New and the insanity of that aspiration has already been set up at the beginning the film. That known map, laid over the new, isn’t going to work, and we are awed with the crazed energy exerted, and enslaved, toward that effort. At first we are even sympathetic with Aguirre who seems to understand that the old institutions have no place here, such as in the scene where he comprehends the futility of the sacrifice required to retrieve from a raft on the far side of the river, in the trap of a whirlpool, the bodies of some of the party who have died, so that they may be carried home for a Christian burial on consecrated land. Aguirre, beginning to act on his own initiative, has the bodies blown up, which seems utterly sensible–or at least it does to me. But then, when he overthrows the Powers That Be, declaring independence (in essence, the first formal Declaration of Independence from the Old World of those transplanted to the new), as he forges ahead we find that he’s just as ruthless in his quest for power and fame, the gold of El Dorado inspiring others but despised by him and only useful as an inspiring tool.

But never mind right now the madness of Aguirre. Instead, here are the others on the raft, floating down the Amazon into chaos, moving further and further away from the old maps, unable to impose them on this new territory. Their new experiences would be difficult enough to chart, to make comprehensible; they are also now sick and hallucinating. What is real and what’s not, they’ve not a clue any longer, not too far removed from the trips of psychonauts. Eventually, the world of Maya is seemingly revealed, all is profoundly realized as illusory when there is witnessed a European boat with sail hanging high upon a tree (revisited in “Apocalypse Now” with the otherworldly plane and parachute encountered deep in the jungle, hanging in a tree). An individual pointing out the boat, the priest counters that the boat is but a hallucination caused by illness–which must be a mass hallucination as all view it. And Herzog permits the audience to see the boat, to participate in this seeming hallucination in a unifying transcendence delivered via his capable imagination and film and a meager $360,000 (or so) budget.

Row, row, row your boat, gently down the stream. Merrily, merrily, merrily, merrily, life is but a dream.

Fully comprehending now that nothing is as it seems to be, we see then the same individual voicing all is illusory, including the arrow that now appears in his leg.

The arrow, Aguirre points out, is real.

Which is to say that if you’ve climbed so high that you’ve stuck your head through the hole in the sky, then after having taken a little look around, it’s best to come back down and give Caesar the money that’s due him.

It’s said that once you’ve been there, there is no reason to ask why it’s best to climb back down.

Aguirre’s is a doomed journey, or at least it is for those who accompany him. All appear to die in the movie, including Aguirre’s daughter, though her death is unlike the others. As she stands facing the jungle at the end of the raft, Aguirre approaches and finds she has been pierced by an arrow. Yet we have the distinct feeling she hasn’t been slain by the same jungle as the others, Aguirre turning her so that we see the arrow (Aguirre, a real historical character, did eventually kill his daughter who had accompanied him on his final adventure). Aguirre’s raft now populated by a country of monkeys–and the dead–we circle round him as he at last vocalizes for us what has driven him, what still drives him, his vision of the world he remains intent upon founding.

Herzog makes no mention of it but the historical Aguirre’s title, as he began this not very famous journey, was “the keeper of the dead”. That was his capacity. He was to take charge over the possessions of those who died along the way.

Alot of people dying along the way, Aguirre was kind of like a self-made psychopomp, wasn’t he?

Herzog at one point has two indigenous emissaries approach the raft, a man and woman who relate their long anticipation of a golden god who, it was said, would come with smoking sticks (the guns) and complete the creation of the country. These two who come wearing gold have confused the blond Aguirre with that golden god, reminding of the mistaken notion that Moctezuma received Cortes as the returning Quetzalcoatl, that evidence of gold causing those on the raft to believe El Dorado is indeed near.

However, the raft upon which Aguirre floats also reminds of the Golden Boat of the El Dorado legend of the accession of new Musica chiefs, each known as the Gilded Man, who “went about all covered with powdered gold, as casually as if were powdered salt”. As part of the ritual of accession, the Gilded Man would ride upon a raft covered with gold objects to the center of a lagoon, and the center of the lagoon reached, the other chiefs signaling for silence, the Gilded Man would throw into the lagoon the gold in order to pacify its demon which was also their god.

The parent expedition, in a Herzog historical mash-up, is led by Pizarro, who seeing the fierce unnavigable rapids of the Amazon, insists that things will be smoother from here on out. Aguirre, looking at Pizarro like he is mad, counters that the river will consume all who venture in it. Which it does, Aguirre abetting as the self-styled Wrath of God. Aguirre may as well be the treacherous river, even to that end where he is unable to escape it in Herzog’s film.

We know, as does Pizarro, who sends the exploratory party on its way, that yes there will be hostile Indians but no El Dorado, and that yes the river will consume those who think it tamable as the horse that the party carries along with them, used to frighten the Indians. The horse is finally pitched off the raft on the order of Guzman in a pique of characteristic irritation, Guzman being the King of El Dorado who Aguirre has set up, given false purpose there in the jungle, Aguirre manufacturing for him even a makeshift throne. The horse tries to climb back on the raft but, unable, it struggles to the shore and stares out of the jungle after the raft like an Old World ghost, an omen of doom which Herzog shows Aguirre reflecting on but doesn’t reveal his thoughts, unless his feelings are divined in Guzman immediately being found strangled beside the outhouse.

The historical Aguirre trained stallions.

The historical Aguirre wholeheartedly confessed to killing Guzman. But Herzog doesn’t show this. He doesn’t show the source of a number of the deaths. The medium yes, but not the source. After the boat is sighted in the trees, one which we guess supposedly belonged to Francisco de Orellan (a lost explorer, another mission of this expedition being to look for any trace of what had happened to his party), it is Aguirre who interrupts the hallucinatory daze, reordering nature, reestablishing the divide between what is real and what is not, because Aguirre is like fate is like the Wrath of God is like the river and the jungle and every single indigenously flung arrow…and not the river at all, the river simply being what it is. A mad god, one begins to feel he has been there before and forgotten. When he goes to his daughter and turns her so we see the arrow in her belly, it is as though he has forgotten he was the bow and the hand which held it.

I don’t know where Herzog came up with this idea of the boat with sail observed hanging upon a tree, but we all of us wonder how, how, how did it get up there…perhaps the flooding river? Impossible, that it could reach up so high, but there is the boat, after all, there is the boat. Perhaps a little like other old world boats ferried by a wrathful god’s watery retribution to the highest mountaintops.

Who has been there before and what did they leave behind?

Some cultures more than others acknowledge, even if only through curious asides, the great shadow of the primordial elusive that may fall near one, a terrifying bird of prey that no one reputable person has seen but has been reported to snatch up the occasional unfortunate (there is this story) and spirit them away to its mountain top home, wherever that may be. The very breath of its wings is hallucinatory magic and can drive the unfortunate few, those without an institutional pillar to lean upon, to madness…or a fool’s journey. Don’t look if you can help it, but if you do, there are the curious asides left by those who have traveled before one.

When the fairy tales turn lively and say, “I hear you need someone to talk to,” it will very likely be at a place in the river between when something like Orellan’s boat appears in its tree and the mad, amnesiac Aguirre calls one’s attention to the reality of the arrows.


Posted

in

by

Comments

7 responses to “Some notes after viewing "Aguirre, the Wrath of God"”

  1. Jim McCulloch Avatar
    Jim McCulloch

    OK, I’ve put Aguirre on my Netflix list. Don’t know why I’ve never seen it before.

  2. Idyllopus Avatar

    Am interested to hear what you think about it.

  3. Jim McCulloch Avatar
    Jim McCulloch

    Well, I watched Aguirre, and I can’t say immediately how I feel about it–it usually takes me a week or two for extraneous thoughts and emotions to damp out, leaving me with whatever I will come away from a movie with.

    One difficulty though, trivial but major at the same tiime, involved suspension of disbelief. Turns out it is _very_ hard for me to handle a Spanish conquistador movie in German with English subtitles. Something about German is so profoundly unlike Spanish that it jarred me every time anyone spoke. (One thing cracked me up, that should not have, when on the raft someone announces that der kaiser is tod, which my mind momentarily heard, and visualized, as the kaiser is toad.) Supposedly the movie was originally filmed in English and later dubbed into German (yes, I just looked it up, where I also find that Kinski’s voice in Aguirre is NOT Kinski’s voice; he wanted too much money for the dubbing, and they got someone else! This is according to Wikipedia, the source of all misinformation, so the factoid may not be true.)

    Kinski’s mannered performance was, as we say, interesting. Little odd touches, probably the director’s doing, seemed right to me, Kinski’s pink blouse somewhat in dishabille, revealing delicate feminine shoulders under his armor, for example.

    Herzog thought he had created a role mad enough for kinski but actually I think Kinski may have been too mad for the role–I will probably have to wait for things to settle out. I don’t know what to think of the daughter as magic bride stuff.

    So I have little to say about the movie, but all of this reminds me of my brother-in-law.

    Kay’s next older sister was one of the first peace corps contingents sent to Peru, in 1963, where she met and fell in love with Herbert Weber, a handsome former Hitler Jugend member and German soldier (captured at Stalingrad, & spent the rest of the war in considerable privation as a Russian POW) who had mysteriously made his way to Peru after the war and by the time Beth, the sister, met him he was the head chef of a ritzy country club where Peace Corps volunteers were not supposed to go but were often invited by wealthy local men for the purpose of hitting on them. In Beth’s case, it was the cook who hit on her, apparently smitten by her golden hair, a turn of events which no doubt displeased whoever had brought her.

    Before he became a chef, however, Herbert had married a Peruvian woman, but she shortly ran off with someone else, to Herbert’s enduring bitterness (even now) and then in a fit of despondency he had driven a recently purchased decrepit bus on terrifying roads over the Andes into the Amazon jungle to start a business (eventually with his younger brother Werner) collecting curare, which had medicinal uses as a muscle relaxant.

    Well, the business did not prosper; for one thing, the barrels of curare tended to ferment and one of them exploded and would have killed Werner if the shrapnel had created an open wound, but instead it merely drenched him with the poison-dart juice, but they lost the barrel and its contents. Apparently this happened often enough that they became bankrupt, plus a German pharmaceutical company had found a better muscle relaxant, perhaps saving the curare plants from extinction; so then Herbert and Werner used the bus to start a bus route on muddy local roads in the rainforest towns. That business failed also, and I remember a story but forget details involving the loss of everything in a flood, except for Herbert’s shoes which were recovered and returned by indians because they were size 14 and obviously had to belong to the tall German. (Werner is short.)

    Before the war, Herbert had been through a rigorous multi-year cooking apprenticeship in Germany, so when the brothers made their way back to Lima, Herbert got a job as a cook in a country club, and soon rose to be head chef. Beth married him (after Herbert, a good Catholic, paid a lot of money for a Church annulment of his original marriage), and she got kicked out of the Peace Corps, at which time they returned to the US.

    Herbert btw is 20 years older than Beth, and at 87 he is getting pretty decrepit. He still has a lot of stories in incomprehensible English about his adventures. (He speaks excellent Spanish with a terrible German accent, but English still eludes him, after al these years.)

    The point is, if there is one, that the Aguirre The Movie for some reason reminded me of Herbert, who is nothing like Kinski, but perhaps a little like the real Aguirre.

  4. Idyllopus Avatar

    (Damn it! Returning to my chair after putting on a pot of water for coffee, I catch my finger between the arm of the chair and the bottom plane of the desk top, which are the same height. Ow! Second time I’ve done that in three days and it hurts!)

    Great stories about your brother-in-law. Thank you for those. I still insist you have several books in you but have reconciled myself to the probability you’re not going there.

    And maybe I shouldn’t go here…

    But you think he may be more like the real Aguirre? Do you mean you believe the real Aguirre is not the ruthless killer he has been made out to be, and even professed to being in his letter to King Philip?

    Aguirre, he frames it all as a matter of survival, and perhaps it was, but he’s given as being as brutal as Francisco de Caravajal.

    I’m wondering now what you think Aguirre’s true character may have been as opposed to what has been passed down.

    It’s said that Aguirre murdered his daughter prior his execution, “because someone that I loved so much should not come to be bedded by uncouth people.” So I imagine that is where Werner got the idea for the “magical bride”, his daughter having traveled with him through all this. But I also took Werner’s use of this as metaphorical.

    I had thought this book sounded interesting, “Sin, Crimes and Retribution in Early Latin America, A Translation and Critique of Sources–Lope De Aguirre, Francisco De Carvajal, Juan Rodriguez Freyle”, but I only find it is now available for $120. Another ouch. Don’t think so.

    It would never occur to me in a million years to try to make a living off poison-dart juice.

    Today that makes me sigh a little sadly over my lack of imagination.

    By the way, your mention of the Hitler Jugend inspired me to look for some literature on them and I came across what looks like a great book, recommended for the 5th to 8th grade set. I’ll be getting it for H.o.p., I think. At least it’s presently in my Amazon cart.

    I used to know a German whose mother had been Hitler Jugend. At the time, he said she still went to reunions.

  5. Jim McCulloch Avatar
    Jim McCulloch

    No, I have no profound insight into Lope de Aguirre, what I meant was that Herbert is a tougher customer than his kindly and jovial manner today might indicate. He told me once that when his wife ran off that he would have killed her if he could have found her, and good catholic that he is, he considers it a sin to lie or exaggerate, so it is a good thing all around that he couldn’t find her. He is kind of a fanatical catholic, actually. He also believes he has a charmed life, which in his view explains his survival of the war and Russian captivity.

    Also, I am not sure that Kinski’s interpretation of Aguirre is right, but that’s based on nothing at all.
    The University of Texas library has the book with the long title you mentioned, but it is unavailable at the moment–otherwise I would check it out–and the reason is that it is currently being digitized, which should mean that at some point it will be available online, presumably for all, if I remember how the digitization program is supposed to work. So you may be able to read it online, but I don’t know the time line for that.

    I put a hold on it for when it gets back from digitization, so at some point I should be able to read the paper copy.

  6. Idyllopus Avatar

    So, I will be able to read it online but you’ll be able to read it sooner. Thanks for checking into this and letting me know.

    Kinski was in the war so he may have based his character a little on what he’d observed. I read that when he went into the movie he was coming off the theatrical tour, Jesus. Herzog said he was very difficult to talk to when he arrived in South America as he kept responding out of this role, as Jesus, but I don’t know exactly what this means because his interpretation of Jesus was a violent maniac. Needless to say many had problems with this interpretation and Herzog’s “My Best Fiend” opens with a clip from the tour and a heated altercation with the audience.

    Ha. It is a sin to lie or exaggerate but his truant wife would have deserved death?

    Perhaps he didn’t look too hard for her.

  7. Jim McCulloch Avatar
    Jim McCulloch

    Herbert no longer drives, thank God, but in the years he did I would not get in a car with him nor would Kay, nor would we allow Eve or Anna to. When he got to America, he got a job as a cook at a place called the Salado Inn, in a small town about 60 miles north of where he and Beth were living in south Austin. (He soon rose to be chef, and then, until he retired, general manager. It’s a popular place and he made quite a good living.) So every morning at 4 he would get up and drive 60 miles up I-35 to work in less than 45 minutes. If he was running late he would make it in half an hour. He had every known kind of radar detector in his car, and he only got a ticket about once a year, but even so his car insurance must have been horrendous.
    But he drove that way everywhere. Since he believed that God was protecting him it never occurred to him that he was endangering anyone else, because he figured he would never have a wreck, and he didn’t. But I still wouldn’t get in the car with him.
    I don’t know if he would have shot his first wife, given an opportunity. If nothing else I think Werner, who unlike Herbert is very easy-going, would have stopped him. Werner btw also came to the US, where he started a succession of failed businesses, including a worm farm, which everyone called Verner’s Verm farm, and Werner would say, yes, my verm farm. You can feel like you are in an inspector Clouseau movie talking to him. Herbert on the other hand has been much more financially successful, and owns 6 rent houses and land and horses and feels that America has blessed him by enabling him to become a country gentleman, though he works too hard to be a country gentleman (an idea he would be puzzled by–“don’t country gentlemen verk?”)

    He suffers from asthma and is in very poor health, but he mows the lawns on all 6 of his rent houses with his riding lawnmower, and then goes home and has a severe asthma attack each time, but he will not pay anyone to mow a lawn as long as he is alive.

    I went ahead and put my best fiend on my netflix list.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *